Church of the Highlands Exposed: A Timeline of Controversies and Scandals

The Church of the Highlands, a megachurch based in Birmingham, Alabama, has been a significant religious institution since its inception in 2001. Known for its large congregation and influential presence, the church has, however, been embroiled in various controversies and scandals over the years. This article aims to provide a comprehensive timeline of these events, examining the implications and the responses of the church’s leadership.

The Foundation and Rapid Growth

Founded in February 2001, Church of the Highlands held its first service at the Fine Arts Center of Mountain Brook High School in Birmingham, Alabama. It was established by Pastor Chris Hodges and quickly garnered attention for its dynamic worship style and community outreach initiatives. The church’s philosophy, focused on reaching people who do not know God personally and fostering relationships through small groups, contributed to its rapid growth. The life-giving message of the Gospel, the enthusiasm of Sunday services, and the church’s simplistic style attracted a large number of attendees, leading to its expansion across multiple locations.

Early Leadership Controversies

In the early years of the Church of the Highlands, the leadership faced significant challenges. One of the earliest controversies involved Dino Rizzo, the senior pastor of the Healing Place Church in Baton Rouge, Louisiana. Rizzo resigned from his position in 2012 following an inappropriate affair. Subsequently, he was reinstated at the Church of the Highlands by Pastor Chris Hodges. Hodges cited Rizzo as a major inspiration for his ministry, lauding his spiritual guidance despite the moral failing​​​​.

Another notable incident was the removal of Michael Hodges, son of Church of the Highlands founder Chris Hodges, from his ministerial position due to a moral failing. The details of this incident were not extensively publicized, but it raised questions about the church’s internal governance and the accountability of its leaders​​.

Sexual Harassment Lawsuit

A pivotal moment in the church’s history was a sexual harassment lawsuit involving Jason Delgado, a church official. The lawsuit alleged that Delgado used his position to engage in inappropriate sexual behavior with a church member, Mrs. Eagan. The failure of the church’s officials, including Pastor Mike Stephens and Stacy Peterson, to intervene effectively after being informed of the harassment was a critical aspect of the lawsuit. This incident highlighted significant concerns about the church’s handling of sexual misconduct allegations and the protection of its congregation members​​.

Restoration Process and Its Critiques

The Church of the Highlands’ approach to dealing with moral failures within its leadership, particularly through a restoration process, has been a subject of debate. This process involved several pastors accused of sexual misconduct, including Josh Mauney, Caleb Treat, and Jason Delgado. Notably, Micahn Carter, accused of rape, was part of this restoration process before being removed following a lawsuit escalation. The church’s investment in facilities and programs for the restoration of pastors implicated in moral failures was criticized by some as being more protective of the leaders than addressing the needs of the victims​​​​.

Racial Controversy and Response

Pastor Chris Hodges faced criticism for liking racially insensitive social media posts, leading to a public outcry. Hodges responded with apologies and commitments to work on initiatives to improve race relations within the church. He emphasized the importance of unity and reconciliation, acknowledging the need for the church to be actively involved in addressing racial issues. This incident was a stark reminder of the broader societal challenges of racism and the role of church leadership in fostering a culture of inclusiveness and understanding​​.

Financial and Ethical Concerns

The Church of the Highlands has also faced scrutiny over its financial practices and ethical standards. Criticisms have been raised regarding the transparency of the church’s finances and the prioritization of church leaders over regular members. This scrutiny is part of a larger conversation about the ethical responsibilities of megachurches, where the balance between financial stewardship and spiritual accountability is often challenging to maintain​​.

Read also:How to Find the Best Home Security Services Near Me ServLeader


The Church of the Highlands, with its significant influence and large following, has faced a series of challenges that have brought into question its leadership accountability, ethical practices, and the handling of serious allegations. These controversies highlight the complexities inherent in managing a large religious organization and the responsibilities that come with it. As the Church of the Highlands continues to address these issues, its responses and actions will be closely watched by both its congregation and the wider religious community. The future of the church, in light of these controversies, remains a topic of significant interest and importance.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *